Mentoring Students Pursuing Non-Academic Careers

Mentoring Students Pursuing Non-Academic Careers

February 6, 2018
Mentoring Students Seeking Non-Academic Careers - two people sit at an office table talking and taking notes

Professors are usually most comfortable mentoring students to follow in our footsteps, but increasingly students are looking at careers outside the academy. Even if they aren’t already, they need to be as the academic job market continues to be an ugly terrain. How can you mentor students pursing non-academic careers, especially if you do not have career experience outside the academy to share with them?

Be open to student choices

Students can be wary of telling us they are considering non-academic careers, worried that to do so is to admit some kind of failure. Mentoring students means being open to where they are, not where we might want them to go. Make sure your mentees know that you support whatever choices they make.

You can signal this by asking open-ended questions that make it clear that you expect they might choose to head out of the academy. Be encouraging, and fight that urge to push your mentees toward your own path.

Our job as mentors is to listen and really hear what our students need, and figure out how we can be helpful given our own skills and connections.

Think broadly about your skills and connections

It might seem easier to mentor those with similar career goals to your own, but when our mentees are considering other paths, it is important to figure out what you can still offer.

What experiences do you have that are relevant to your mentee’s non-academic career plans? How can your own skills translate to other areas? Did you consider non-academic careers yourself, or do you have work experience outside the academy that might be relevant?

It can be incredibly helpful for mentees to hear about your own experiences choosing—or not choosing—academic careers. Much of mentoring is about listening and offering support, and those are things you can do regardless of your own career choices.

Research and recommend resources on non-academic careers

As academic mentors we are used to recommending academic resources first and foremost. We can help our mentees by doing research and recommending resources that specifically address concerns of those seeking non-academic or alternative academic (altac) careers. While these resources will most importantly help mentees find mentorship that helps, signaling them signals to our mentees that we support their choices. Here are few to start with:

Ideas on Fire

Beyond the Professoriate

  • This thriving post-academic community offers tools and advice for building careers outside the academy

From Ph.D. to Life

  • Jennifer Polk offers personal coaching to help dissertators and recent PhDs clarify and articulate personally meaningful career goals

Inside Higher Ed

  • Great advice for preparing for work outside the academy while still getting trained inside

Alt-ac Advisor

  • Published by Joshua Cracraft, Alt-ac Advisor guides students in the difficult work of deciding to leave the academy and offers practical advice on how to position oneself for and find a career outside of it

Disciplinary professional organizations

Whether it’s the Modern Language Association, the American Psychological Association, the National Women’s Studies Association, or the American Studies Association, check out their resources. As more and more graduate students choose to leave the academy for personal and systemic reasons, professional organizations are offering their own guides for helping expand what we imagine we can do with our PhDs.

Know your limits

When mentees look outside the academy for careers, it is tempting to think you know enough to offer helpful mentorship. In many ways you do.

It is important, though, to understand your own limits. Writing and publishing as academics, for example, is really different from building a freelance public writing career. Some of your own experiences are relevant, and some aren’t. Avoid thinking you know more than you do about non-academic careers.

This is the time to think about other people who might make good mentors—former students or colleagues who have gone on to non-academic careers, people inside the university who have different careers or side jobs outside of it, and friends in other lines of work who might be able to step in. Sometimes the best thing we can do as mentors is to help our mentees find better mentors that we could be.

Join our newsletter

Get articles, podcast episodes, and event announcements sent straight to your inbox

    Our privacy policy

    Related Stories

    Writing and Publishing Your First Book - Wood desk with white keyboard, earbuds, and coffee cup
    April 2, 2018

    Writing and Publishing Your First Book

    How to identify your audience, craft a strong frame, revise the argument, and find the best publisher for your first book/tenure book.

    Responding to Reviewer Comments - Person leans against a wall, writing on a tablet. Photo by WOC in Tech Chat.
    May 16, 2017

    Responding to Reader Reports: The Big Picture

    2-part series on how to tackle the reviewer comments you received on your academic book or article. Big-picture advice on approaching the process.

    Preparing for Fall Pandemic Edition - Colorful fall trees arched over a winding road
    August 4, 2020

    Preparing for Fall, the Pandemic Edition

    Tips on preparing for fall semester during a pandemic, including accessible online teaching and public engagement during social distancing.