Manage Grading Without Getting Overwhelmed

Manage Grading Without Getting Overwhelmed

May 2, 2017

Manage Grading without Getting Overwhelmed - Giant jumbled pile of papers, notebooks, and books

Grading is one of the most challenging, thankless, and important parts of teaching. When the end of the semester draws near, finals loom for students and final grades loom for instructors.

Grading is at once an intellectually demanding task that requires focus and concentration, and monotonous work that necessitates patience and a high degree of organization.

If the prospect of wading through a pile of papers and exams feels more than a little daunting, we’ve got some helpful suggestions for staying on top of grading without getting overwhelmed.

Take It On Little By Little

Easier said than done, but approaching grading with a holistic plan at the start of the semester (rather than in desperation at the end) can work wonders for alleviating your stress around finals time.

Create a spreadsheet tracking each students’ grades from the start of the semester onward. It is a lot easier to keep on top of adding in a few grades each week as you go through assignments than trying to tally them all at the end of the semester, especially if you are teaching various courses.

Some schools use learning management software like Canvas to help you track assignments, but it can help to have a backup spreadsheet.

This step is especially important for adjunct instructors teaching at various universities that each may use different grade tracking systems.

Don’t Bite Off More Than You Can Chew

Approach grading practically—and strategically. A small but vital step is to use a timer to set a strict amount of time to spend on grading each paper or exam. Try experimenting with the first few to find a time frame that works, and then be sure to stick to it!

If possible, try not to grade more than 4-6 large assignments a day or your eyes will glaze over. A little each day is more manageable than all at once.

Be sure to also give yourself a brief (maybe even timed) break between each assignment and a longer break between groups of papers, especially if you have only a few days to get through everything.

Focus Is Key, but Support Is Important

Grading is an intensely demanding task requiring a lot of focus, time, and mental (and even emotional) energy. As much as possible, set aside dedicated time for it; do not try to grade while responding to email, calling people back, or waiting in between meetings. It is almost impossible to multi-task while grading. Disconnecting from other responsibilities, even for a short time, can be a crucial step in making a dent on your grading pile.

That said, grading with friends and colleagues can be a huge boon to getting it done! A supportive environment can help you stay focused and relax in the interim. Even changing your environment, tackling the task somewhere that is not your normal work space, can help you stay focused by breaking up the monotony.

Be Intentional and Strategic in Your Feedback

When giving feedback on papers in particular, be strategic. If you have a rubric, make sure your comments clearly and consistently reflect its standards. In the case of assignments that need a lot of work, consider meeting with the student in person if time allows. Talking through more complex issues can sometimes be more effective and efficient than to try to accurately give written feedback on an assignment that needs a total overhaul.

And while individual feedback is important, on papers especially, don’t be afraid to use a template for opening and closing statements. Opening lines like “you are a strong writer…this is a solid essay…you do a good job of supporting your points with evidence…you demonstrate a strong understanding of the readings we’ve covered in class so far this semester” and closing statements like “overall, nice work!” can be copied and pasted between assignments for efficiency.

Be Attentive to Tone

Even when evaluating work that is not strong, try to keep the tone positive. Clearly emphasize what went wrong, but focus on what the student can fix and improve. Start your feedback with something—anything—positive, no matter how minor. If there is nothing exceptionally good about the work, focus on what has improved from previous work or what shows potential.

With this approach in mind, also make sure that your feedback is focused on the assignment itself and does not read as a judgment of your student’s character. Be careful not to make assumptions about why an essay wasn’t edited or why a student misread the assignment. You can and should point out what went wrong but shouldn’t presume to know the reason why a student performed poorly.

As frustrating as it can be to evaluate inadequate work, try to approach the task with some compassion. Students, like you, have a lot going on in their lives, and things like stress, trauma and inexperience, especially for students that don’t come from a privileged background, can all influence their performance.

Sign up for our newsletter

Podcast episodes, articles, and offers right to your inbox to help you rock your interdisciplinary career

Our Privacy Policy

Related Stories

Ideas on Fire's Favorite Literature - Open notebook with pages folded into a heart
July 4, 2017

Ideas on Fire’s All-Time Favorite Novels and Other Literature

The Ideas on Fire team LOVES to read. Here are some of our all-time favorite novels and other literature that make us see the world differently.

Weekend Reading - Orange tabby cat wearing glasses reading from an open book
May 18, 2017

Weekend Reading: Emotional Labor in the Academy

Academics are getting better at talking openly about the intellectual and physical work academia demands. But the requisite emotional labor is often more difficult to identify and manage. As we finally name the mental health crisis in higher education, our latest weekend reading reflects on its invisible emotional terrain.

October 10, 2016

Academic Book Marketing: Audience & Author Platform

How to identify your academic book's audience and build an author platform that gets your book noticed, purchased, and engaged by that audience.